A row has broken out in the poetry world, over whether poetry should be learned by heart at school.The new idea for English Literature examinations is that rather than write a piece on poems aided by an anthology, candidates should learn 15 poems to quote in the examination. It was the idea of the previous Secretary for Education, but one that has divided the poetry world. Their fear is that it may put children off poetry for life.
At school I had to learn the multiplication tables and have forever been glad about that. But learning Psalms by rote and the Catechism were less useful or memorable. I think there must be a middle way through all this, committing some things to memory but only carefully selected ones. Various well known poets have given their views, but they are by no means all one way.A consensus seemed to be that it had its advantages but only through encouragement and not by making them compulsory. For a University examination I had to learn Plato's 'Republic' virtually by rote, because the exam could offer any sentence for comment and review. I have been quite glad of that over the years.
I venture the thought that getting to know a topic word by word, poem or otherwise, is best when we do it because loving familiarity has done it for us.This is certainly the case for many Methodist folk who love their hymns and regard the hymn book as a prayer book. How well we remember the verses of favourite hymns, often word-perfect as well, but only because they are so loved and valued. Having written this I must admit that I have often challenged congregations to get to know their hymn book better.
I have written a few poems (verses or rhymes really) and always remember one piece of timeless valuable advice- make sure every line 'pulls its weight'. Then may I suggest that there is no better example of this than Charles Wesley's hymns(poems) . Just one example of a packed line of meaning:
'Our God contracted to a span, incomprehensibly made man'
We want to know and value a hymn like that.
...............................................................................................................................
Yesterday we attended 'Cafe Worship' at our church. Tables and chairs instead of chairs in straight lines.Tea and cake to follow.Much chatter encouraged and sitting down for the songs(Question: Why do we always have to stand up?).
It was a worthy attempt to set us on a different course and should be an example to each to seek new ways.
No comments:
Post a Comment