Monday, 21 March 2016

NATURE AND NURTURE

Those who read my daily pieces quite often may ask themselves 'what is he reading that for? aware that the subject matter is a long way out of my field of interest. Well you must first remember that I am . a 'skimmer' who hunts for information, research reports and much more . Secondly to realise that if I get into an area (as today for example) I may well have done nothing more than read a book review. So let me explain where we are today.

It is about who we are and whether that arises from nurture or nature. Did we inherit our personalities, the people we are now because of our genes or because of our environment. You know the old defence 'he gets that from his mother' or equally 'she gets all that from her father'. Now you will have already thought this before you read it, but the question is not all or nothing but the balance of the two factors.

Scientific evidence from twins over decades have shown  that differences we can observe for any given characteristic can be separated into those inborn, that is genetic,and those determined by non-genetic factors which we loosely call the environment. Without surprise the results seem to come out at 50;50 over many studies and many years. For those who encounter people in ways that require caring and understanding the implications are clear. The bigger question is can those inherited forces be changed for good if that is necessary and helpful?

A learned book has just been published (the Review of which I have read) which says that virtually all characteristics come from patterns of nature from parents and grandparents. As you will imagine this caused interesting responses and in the particular view I read the argument for 100% nurture was treated as nonsensical and against all scientific norms. In that strange phrase the reviewer said that the writer of the book had confused absence of evidence with evidence of absence (the latter being the more powerful case.

This is pretty inconclusive but is an interesting puzzle for us to look at ourselves and our parents and our children and see if we can identify evidence both ways. I think I can. To take just one aspect there are things I recall in my father- lovely things- that I wish had been passed naturally to me, but alas if I want them they have be cultivated.

But there is a bigger issue here which interests me, especially as one wanting to be apologetic for the Christian Faith.How experts (so called) continue to get it wrong and disagree with one another.So when we read arguments against God or a spiritual world just say to yourself 'Who are you to make these claims' Have you got evidence of absence or is there simply absence of evidence, two very different scenarios.

No comments:

Post a Comment