Wednesday, 17 April 2013

PART ONE- PREPARING FOR THE FUNERAL

I should first make a comment that what is written here is apolitical, especially so as I did not vote for Mrs Thatcher(as she then was) on any occasion. That does not stop me honouring her today.
The response to her death has been shockingly divided, even to the extent of demonstration displaying real hatred. But, returning to my familiar theme of the importance of perspectives, we need to take a long look at her life, given that we may not yet be far enough away to get a true perspective. Former US President Ronal Reagan was much reviled but as we take the long view of those days, many now say that his intransigence brought the cold war to a end(Gorbachev was convinced that Reagan would never give way on Star Wars).

We should also have in mind that there is probably no one perspective, each of these emerging from how the individual was affected by that historic event or person. The miners felt the impact of closed coalmines and job loss; the unions felt their power diminished; the other industries that felt the benefit. One interesting perspective I encountered only this week was that twice as many mines were closed in the Wilson era than in the Thatcher years. So who can really tell a complete story?

Then there is the person behind the image and policies. By most accounts(not one story but many cameos) Margaret Thatcher was a very kind and compassionate person. 'She wasn't in public' comes the cry. Perhaps not but the other side is her human kindness. I heard an interview with the man who was her driver before and after her time in office (he refused the offer to be John Major's driver, preferring to stay with his former boss- a compliment in itself).
Yet another aspect of this perspective business is the necessary distinction between intention and outcome.Different criteria, you see. It was (we know this from those in her confidence) she hoped that the result of her policies would be a more giving societ It turned out to be a new impetus to the grabbing society.So how do we judge her in this regard? By intention or outcome?

All this shows me how complex any analysis really is. In this light I will watch the funeral and be thankful for an individual who did her best(whether rightly or wrongly) to serve the public.

No comments:

Post a Comment